I'll admit that this Yankee-loathing Mets fan was stirred by Curt Schilling's leadership and guts in leading the Red Sox past New York and the Cardinals for Boston's first world championship since 1918. You know the story, and the images - the bloody sock, the temporary tendon surgery, and the greatest comeback in sports history. And then Schilling, fresh from the victory parade, went to New Hampshire to campaign for Bush-Cheney ticket. Pop went that bubble.
There should have been no surprise. Pro athletes tend to be a fairly Republican bunch, and for all the traditional reasons: they're rich and desire to pay less in taxes. But in this year of the great culture war - of the battle between hard-core blue state people and red state people over so-called values - why did Bush yield such a bumper crop of ballplayers? And why don't they count as part of the entertainment elite? How come no one's writing a companion book to shrill conservative Laura Ingraham's Shut Up and Sing called Shut Up and Play?
If you're both a Democrat and a Yankee fan, you need to suspend any belief that the political actions of athletes make a difference, that your on-field heroes should align with your party affiliation. After all, Alex Rodriguez and Joe Torre each gave President Bush $2,000 toward reelection. Derek Jeter and Don Mattingly make several lists of prominent Republican athletes. GM Brian Cashman famously told Mike Lupica this season, "I'm a Republican." And George Steinbrenner - renowned (ok, convicted, as Billy Martin pointed out) for his support of Richard Nixon - gave $5,000 this cycle to the Florida Republican Committee. Buy hey, Steinbrenner also gave to the campaigns of Democrats Chuck Schumer and Charlie Rangel, and back-up first-baseman Tony Clark is an active Democrat.
Being a Mets fan and political southpaw is no easier. Al Leiter is planning a political career in the GOP, Tom Glavine supported Bush (even though his parents are Kennedy Democrats from Massachusetts), and Mike Piazza publicly cheered when the Republican convention came to town. Fred Wilpon gave a couple grand to Bush-Cheney (but as with the Boss, also gave to Schumer).
Carlos Beltran, Nolan Ryan, Craig Biggio, Jack Nicklaus, Karl Malone, Roger Staubach, Ernie Banks. Just a few of the famous athletes who endorsed Bush this year, although not many give their riches to politicians. John Kerry? A couple of gymnasts no one's ever heard of. NFL player and Bush supporter Jason Sehorn (the former Giant) explained it this way:
"In most of the locker rooms you'll find a little more Republican (support) than Democrat, at least thinking and leaning towards that way. I think because we understand that, you know, we're very capable and adept at taking care of ourselves, and we don't need somebody to place a lot of regulations. I mean, put things in place so I can take care of myself and protect me."
Ethnicity seems to have nothing to do with it; indeed, nowhere has the Republican Party made such strong inroads with black and Hispanic than with pro athletes. Tiger Woods is reportedly leaning Republican, and is the topic of speculation about his relationship with President Bush and a future political career on the GOP side of the ledger. Why? Well, take the example of slugger Frank Thomas, who told the Chicago Tribune in 1996 that he came from a family of Democrats but started voting straight Republican. "I'm a rich man now," Thomas told the paper. "It's bad to say that, but it's the truth. Taxes are out of hand for people making a certain amount of money."
Or Tiger's friend Charles Barkley, who has hinted that he's interested in running for governor of Alabama as a Republican. When Barkley's mother complained to him that only the rich were Republicans, he said, "Mama, I am the rich."
It's not all grim and doom on the Democrats' side. Michael Jordan backed Barak Obama's bid for the Senate early on, in the primary. Lance Armstrong came out against Bush and the Iraq war. Larry Bird campaigned for Democratic candidates in Indiana. And the owners of the Red Sox gave early and gave often to the campaign of native son John Kerry. Greats like Hank Aaron, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Bill Walton, John McEnroe, Andre Agassi and Franco Harris are all active Democrats. We're not shut out completely.
I like the sports for the action and in the case of baseball, for the poetry. I'm not going to root on the basis of politics. And while I admit I'm long past the age of identifying with athletes on a personal level, I'd prefer the locker rooms of my favorite teams to be a bit more politically balanced, like the electorate itself.
But there is something to this GOP jockocracy thing and it's not going away. Does it go beyond the protect-my-fortune instinct? I'm not sure - let me know what you think - but as I ponder this I can't help but recall my all-time favorite Republican and my all-time favorite baseball player are the same person. Yes, Jackie Robinson voted GOP.